Insurrection at the Capitol, Five Years Later: January 6 Images as Networked Memories
LESS INFO

ABSTRACT

Why is January 6th remembered so differently by American publics? How do cultural memories of January 6th compare to past media events such as Watergate or 9/11? Our cultural memories are mediated in new ways that I theorize as networked. By networked memories, I mean that cultural recollections of January 6th are formed not just through photographs, videos, eyewitness accounts and television coverage, but also by Reddit forums, tweets, Instagram Reels and TikToks, YouTube videos, AI-generated content and, of course, memes. These Internet-born “memory media” are fluid; they circulate, reproduce and shift at greater speeds than traditional media. Algorithmic mediation impacts their reach, as American publics consume content which aligns with and validates their pre-existing political beliefs. This digital ethnographic account of January 6th’s cultural mediations draws together literature on scandal, spectacle, mass media and the public sphere to work through the ‘memed’ cultural memories of January 6th. I demonstrate how collective recollections of January 6th are siloed, dispersed, constantly shifting, melting and re-forming, echoing the logics of the platforms which mediate memory today; arguing that a networked conception of mediated memory enables us to better understand why January 6th is (mis)remembered in so many ways. 

METHODS

I tracked how Win McNamee’s photograph of a January 6th insurrectionist was uploaded to X, then promptly became one of that event’s most viral images after a user confused the “Via Getty” attribition for the insurrectionist’s name. Through advanced search (reverse image search and time-restricted search), I tracked how the photograph was memed and re-memed across X, Reddit and Instagram to incommensurable understandings of January 6th for various networked publics. For some, the image proves a crime was committed. For others, however, the meme version is an artifact of rebellion, patriotism and support for freedom of speech.